Picky Eater? Why 8 to 10 Tries Is Normal (and What Helps)

Picky Eater? Why 8 to 10 Tries Is Normal (and What Helps)

Your baby spits out the carrots, clamps their mouth on the spoon, or throws the peas on the floor. Before you worry, know this: rejecting new foods is a normal part of development, and it can take 8 to 10 tries before a baby accepts a new taste.

Toddler being offered a new food at a calm family meal, showing that repeated tries are normal

Why babies and toddlers resist new foods

  • New tastes and textures are unfamiliar, and that takes time.
  • Appetite changes with growth, teething, and mood.
  • Toddlers are learning independence, and food is one place they can say no.

A framework many dietitians use

Ellyn Satter's Division of Responsibility splits the job in two.

  • Parent decides: what is served, when, and where.
  • Child decides: whether to eat, and how much.

This takes the pressure off both of you. Your job is to offer a variety of foods on a predictable schedule. Your child's job is to eat as much or as little as they need.

What helps

  1. Keep offering. A refused food is not a failed food. Serve it again in a few days, in a different form.
  2. Serve one familiar food alongside a new one, so there is always something baby will eat.
  3. Offer tiny portions. A pea-sized amount is less overwhelming than a heaping spoonful.
  4. Eat together. Babies learn by watching you enjoy the same foods.
  5. Stay neutral. Skip the bribes, pleading, and "one more bite" negotiations.
  6. Let them explore. Touching, squishing, and smelling food count as progress.
  7. Keep the routine. Regular meal and snack times help appetite build between offers.

What to skip

  • Forcing bites or using dessert as a reward.
  • Hiding foods in other foods so baby does not know they are eating them.
  • Making a separate meal every time baby refuses dinner.

When to talk to your pediatrician

Check in if your child eats a very small number of foods, drops foods they used to eat, gags on most textures, is not growing as expected, or if mealtimes cause a lot of distress. Some feeding challenges benefit from extra support.

Mealtime should be a place where kids feel safe to try. A colorful set of Eizzy Baby silicone plates and bowls can make a new food feel like part of the fun. Browse at eizzybaby.com.

Sources: Health Stand Nutrition: Starting Solids Safely; Metro Pediatrics: Starting Your Baby on Solid Foods.

Back to blog

Collapsible content

Disclaimer

The information contained on this blog is for informational and educational purposes only. It is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always seek the advice of your qualified healthcare provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.

Eizzy Baby assumes no responsibility for any actions or decisions taken or omitted to be taken based on the information contained on this blog.

Affiliate Disclosure: This blog may contain affiliate links. This means that if you click on a link and make a purchase, Eizzy Baby may receive a commission. This helps us keep the blog running and continue providing valuable content. We only recommend products that we believe in and use ourselves.

Shop our best sellers